Skip to content

Blog · Buying and selling

Buying a company: what the price does not tell you

Before you buy a company, I analyse the tax and accounting side of what you are buying: whether it is quotas or assets, which tax debts stay with the company, what happens to the tax losses, whether IMT is due because the company owns real estate, and what the customer, inventory and supplier balances actually say. The price, which is negotiated between you and the seller, only makes sense after this.

Quotas or assets: what are you buying?

The first question is whether the purchase is of quotas or of specific assets. The second is what comes with it. Is the property included? Does the cash stay in the company? Are there shareholder loans to be settled? Without these answers, comparing prices means comparing different things.

For tax purposes, they are two different worlds. Whoever buys quotas takes the company as it stands, with its tax history. Whoever buys assets chooses what to take, and it is the selling company that answers for the past. Each structure has its own taxes on the purchase itself and in the following years, and that is what I put into numbers before the buyer chooses.

I also want to know the buyer’s objective. They may want to enter a region, add production capacity or gain a customer portfolio. That reason has to be checked against what the accounts show.

Which balances need the most attention?

A customer balance can combine recent invoices with old amounts whose collection is uncertain. Inventory may include products that are no longer in demand. A debt to suppliers may be being paid normally or involve an unresolved dispute. I separate these situations one by one, because the same figure on the balance sheet can have very different consequences for cash flow and for taxes in the following years.

Is buying quotas buying the liabilities?

Whoever buys the quotas buys the company with everything it owes. Legally, the debts stay with the company, which the buyer now controls, and do not pass to the buyer’s personal assets. Economically, they are the buyer’s: liabilities they did not know about reduce the value of what they bought. If the buyer takes over the management, they may become secondarily liable for the company’s tax debts, but only under certain conditions: debts whose payment deadline ended during their management, or fault on their part in the company’s assets becoming insufficient (General Tax Law (Lei Geral Tributária), article 24). And if the purchase transfers more than half of the share capital or the majority of the voting rights, the company may lose the tax losses it had available to deduct (IRC Code, article 52(8)). There are exceptions, but they must be checked before counting on those losses in the price. That is why the tax analysis has to cover the whole company, and not just the business the buyer is interested in. Buying only the assets is a different structure, with its own liabilities and tax effects, which are checked case by case.

I request the tax and social security clearance certificates and read the returns filed alongside the accounts: VAT (IVA), withholdings, payments on account, outstanding assessments. Anything that does not add up has to be explained before the purchase goes ahead.

Is property transfer tax (IMT) due when the company owns real estate?

There may be, even when buying quotas. The law provides for IMT on the acquisition of holdings in companies more than half of whose assets consist of real estate located in Portugal, not used in an agricultural, industrial or commercial activity, when a shareholder comes to hold at least 75% of the capital. Owning real estate in the company is not enough on its own; I check the three conditions and, if tax is due, it goes into the cost of the purchase before the price is discussed.

Source IMT Code (Código do IMT), article 2(2)(d) (opens in a new window)

What obligations continue after the purchase?

I do not work out the acquisition using only the price and the completion costs. After the purchase, the company still has its tax obligations on the usual dates: VAT, withholdings, payments on account of corporate income tax (IRC). I ask whether the cash left in the company is enough to cover them and to pay salaries and suppliers while customers have not yet paid.

There are expenses that a hasty reading leaves out. I check in the accounts whether there are costs that do not appear, such as depreciation or salaries the owner does not currently draw. If they are not there, the profit the buyer expects rests on incomplete costs.

Example

Buying a competitor’s client portfolio

A services company wants to buy a competitor for its client portfolio. The seller shows stable revenue, but some contracts depend on renewal. The owner is the main commercial contact and wants to leave. Part of what has been invoiced has remained uncollected for quite some time.

The opportunity may be a good one. I read the accounts to separate what has been invoiced, what has been collected and what is still to be collected, and the tax returns to know what stays in the company. In this purchase, the ability to collect what is overdue and the tax debts that come with the quotas may weigh as much as the asking price. That is why the buyer should discuss them with the seller before discussing the price.

How do you integrate the purchase into the existing business?

If the buyer already has a business, I look at what the acquisition changes in its accounts and tax. Two companies or one? A merger, a shareholding or the purchase of the assets by the existing company? Each route has different tax effects: on the losses that are kept, on VAT and on the taxes on the transaction itself.

What the tax review checks, and what stays with the lawyer

Our part is the tax and accounting analysis of the company: the returns filed, the debts and tax losses, the balances and what the documents say about them. The legal due diligence is handled by the team’s lawyer or by the client’s lawyer, and the negotiation of the price and the contract is for the buyer and their lawyer.

At the end of the analysis, I separate what has been confirmed from what remains uncertain. Each uncertain point is described, with its tax effect, for the buyer and their lawyer to decide how to deal with it in the contract. The buyer decides; my job is to make sure they decide with the tax in plain view.

Frequently asked questions

When buying quotas, do the debts pass to the buyer?

Legally, they stay with the company and do not pass to your personal assets. Economically, they are yours: liabilities you did not know about reduce the value of what you bought. That is why the whole company is analysed, and the contract, which the buyer negotiates with their lawyer, protects them with representations and warranties from the seller and, often, with part of the price held back (escrow).

Does buying only the assets avoid the risks?

No: buying only the assets is a different structure, with its own liabilities and tax effects, to be checked case by case.

Does buying quotas (shareholdings in a Lda.) or shares in a company that owns real estate trigger property transfer tax (IMT)?

There may be, when quotas or shares are bought. The law sets three cumulative conditions: more than half of the company’s assets consist of real estate located in Portugal; that real estate is not used in an agricultural, industrial or commercial activity (buying and selling real estate does not count as such); and a shareholder comes to hold at least 75% of the capital, through this purchase or through another event. Owning real estate in the company is not enough, on its own, to conclude that tax is due. Source: IMT Code (Código do IMT), article 2(2)(d) (opens in a new window).

What does the tax review of the target company cover?

The returns filed, tax debts and tax losses, IMT where there is real estate, and the balances that explain the company. Legal due diligence is handled by the team’s lawyer or by the client’s own lawyer; the negotiation is the buyer’s.

Does Segmentos Capital look for companies to buy or negotiate the price?

No. We work on the company the buyer already has in view and explain the taxes and the accounts to them. The search and the negotiation are the buyer’s.

Can the analysis lead to walking away from the purchase?

Yes. It may lead to revising the terms or the price, or to walking away.

Portrait of Paulo Sérgio
Written by

Paulo Sérgio

CEO & CFO

CEO & CFO of Segmentos Capital.

Meet the partners

Have you read something that applies to your company?

Tell us what you are dealing with. The first conversation is for us to understand what you need, and it commits you to nothing.