Preparing succession in a family business means separating three decisions: who takes the holdings, who takes over the management and how those who do not stay are compensated. I start with the taxes of each form of transfer, a gift or a sale of quotas, with the balances between the company and the founder and with what stays in the accounts, before any legal act.
Who keeps the company and who runs it?
When a business owner wants to pass the company on to their children, I ask who wants to work in it and who only wants to keep a stake. These are different positions. Being a shareholder does not settle who negotiates with the bank or oversees the business. Before discussing the transfer, I identify the roles someone will have to keep performing.
I also ask the founder what role they want to keep. Do they want to leave, reduce their involvement or keep deciding on some matters? A succession stalls when ownership changes and authority is left undefined. Whatever is agreed between everyone has to be put in writing, in the articles of association or in a shareholders’ agreement, as appropriate.
How do you compensate the child who does not stay?
There may be one child keen to carry on and another who would rather receive compensation. In that case, I start with the taxes. Gifting the quotas to a child and selling them to that child are routes with different taxes: a gift is a transfer without consideration, subject to Stamp Duty (Imposto do Selo), with the exemption the law grants to descendants; in a sale, the parent may have a capital gain to declare. I calculate both and show the family what each one leaves to each person.
We do not value the company. The value the family places on the compensation is its decision, and inheritance rights are a legal matter. What I put on the table are the taxes and the balances, so that the compensation is discussed with numbers that exist, and not with the history of the company mixed up with expectations that were never compared.
Then you need to know where the money for the compensation comes from. The founder’s personal assets, the company’s cash and the resources of whoever takes over the company are not the same thing, nor do they pay the same taxes. I look at the effect of each solution on the continuity of the business, because an agreement can seem fair and still create payments the company cannot sustain.
What belongs to the company and what belongs to the founder?
In a succession, I look closely at the balances between the company and the shareholders. I look for founder loans not yet clarified, personal assets the company uses and drawings from past years that nobody has identified. All of this is clarified before payments are agreed, because each of these balances has its own tax treatment.
The same applies to the guarantees the founder gave to banks or suppliers. Stepping down as manager or transferring the quotas does not, in itself, make personal liabilities disappear. I ask for the documents and see what was signed, because the consequences depend on that and on how the transfer is made.
Continuing without making everyone run the business
The founder of a distribution company wants to slow down. One of his children works in the business and wants to carry on. The other has their own career and does not want to manage it. Part of the premises belongs to the founder, and the equipment belongs to the company.
I separate what belongs to the company from what belongs to the founder, and the terms of use of the premises, which need to be put in writing and have their own taxes. I look at how the business carries on and what money is needed to meet the agreed payments. In this case, dividing the quotas does not answer the management questions. It still has to be decided who makes the decisions, what information the non-managing shareholder receives and how a future exit is handled.
How does a shareholder leave after the succession?
Succession has to provide for what happens if one of the future shareholders changes plans. I raise this possibility without assuming conflict. How is the consideration for the holding calculated? Who is in a position to pay it? What effect does that payment have on the business and on the taxes of whoever leaves? The articles of association can provide for the redemption of the quota and the method for calculating the consideration, and the law gives a shareholder, in certain cases, the right to withdraw (Companies Code (Código das Sociedades Comerciais), articles 232 to 240). The answers require legal and tax analysis, but asking the questions early helps the family see whether it is accepting commitments it can meet.
Gift or sale: what is the tax effect?
Gifting or selling the quotas has different tax and legal consequences. A gift is a transfer without consideration, subject to Stamp Duty, with the exemption the law grants to transfers to descendants. A sale may give rise to a capital gain for the seller. I do not choose between a gift, a sale or another structure on the basis of a tax difference alone. The heirs’ rights, each shareholder’s situation and the payments involved also weigh. A favourable tax position does not resolve the other questions.
There are specific instruments for the case where one child keeps the company and the other is compensated, such as a lifetime partition (partilha em vida), which allocates the quotas to one child and compensates the other heirs, with everyone’s agreement (Civil Code (Código Civil), article 2029). A gift of quotas to children does not require the company’s consent, unless the articles of association provide otherwise (Companies Code, article 228). The choice is a legal one; we show what each option changes in terms of tax and cash.
At Segmentos Capital, we look at what each decision changes in the accounts and in the taxes. Legal acts are carried out by the team’s lawyer, Maria João Brogueira, or by the client’s own lawyer. Before anything is formalised, I want everyone to be able to explain the same solution: who manages, on what terms, with what obligations and with what taxes. Disagreements are resolved while the proposal can still be revised.
Frequently asked questions
Does the way the quotas are transferred change the taxes?
It may change. A gift is subject to Stamp Duty, with an exemption for descendants; a sale may give rise to a capital gain for the seller. They are compared before choosing, alongside the heirs’ rights.
Does Segmentos Capital value the company for the division of the estate?
No. We calculate the taxes of each form of transfer and clarify the balances between the company and the founder. The amount of the compensation is the family’s decision; inheritance rights are a legal matter.
Does the founder stop being liable for personal guarantees?
That cannot be assumed. It depends on what was signed with banks and suppliers, and it is checked in the documents.
Who carries out the legal work of the succession?
The team’s lawyer, Maria João Brogueira, or the client’s own lawyer. We handle the taxes and the accounts of the transfer.


