Advisory · Technical opinions
Do you need to justify a decision to the bank or the Tax Authority?
A merger, a sale or a capital increase raises questions that a conversation will not settle. We write down the framework, the alternatives and the position the analysis supports, in a signed opinion you can show to whoever asks for it.
Have you received one of these requests?
An opinion almost always starts with someone else’s question.
FromYour bank
SubjectGrounds for the transaction
Before approving the financing, we need to understand the tax and accounting treatment of the transaction the company is about to make.
We write the opinion you can attach to your application to the bank.
FromManagement
SubjectAn open tax question
I have to decide and I still do not know how much tax this option will cost me.
We analyse the question before you decide.
FromThe statutory auditor
SubjectAccounting treatment
We ask for the grounds for the accounting treatment of this transaction.
We justify the accounting treatment.
FromThe Tax Authority
SubjectThe company’s position
The company must present its position on the matter, with the supporting grounds.
We prepare a reasoned position.
What we do
- 01Question
What you need to know and for whom
- 02Framework
What the law and the standards say
- 03Alternatives
The possible options and the effect of each
- 04Opinion
The position the analysis supports, in writing
- 05Third parties
Bank · Auditor · Tax Authority
- Tax opinions
We analyse the tax framework of a specific question for the company.
- Accounting opinions
We examine the accounting treatment applicable to the facts under analysis.
- Prior analysis of transactions
We study the accounting and tax consequences of mergers, demergers, capital injections and sales.
- Reasoning for third parties
We prepare a written position to present to the bank, the statutory auditor or the Tax Authority.
Who the opinion is for
The same transaction can raise different questions for the lender, for the auditor and for whoever assesses the tax treatment.
An unsigned contract, a transaction that changes halfway through or a missing document can change the conclusion. That is why the opinion states the facts on which it is based.
For the bank
When the financing decision requires an accounting or tax explanation of the transaction.
Request an opinionFor the statutory auditor
When the treatment of a situation in the company’s accounts needs to be justified.
Request an opinionFor the Tax Authority
When the company needs to set out a tax position with the supporting reasoning.
Request an opinionCan I request an opinion before selling or restructuring the company?
Yes, the prior analysis can cover a sale, merger, demerger or capital injection. The aim is to examine the accounting and tax framework before the decision. To define the work, tell us the intended transaction and the question that needs an answer.
Does the opinion guarantee that the bank or the AT will accept the transaction?
No, the opinion sets out a reasoned position on the question analysed. The bank and the Tax Authority have their own powers and criteria for the decisions that fall to them. Written reasoning helps to explain the transaction, but does not replace those decisions.
Do I need to be an accounting client to request an opinion?
You do not need to hand your accounting over to us to engage us on a transaction. At first contact, explain what decision is at stake and what question you need answered. There is no need to send documents at that stage.
What question needs a written answer?
Just tell us what you are deciding and who you will present the opinion to.
